SELECTIVE REPORTING...

>> Sunday, June 13, 2010

In it's zeal to create the impression that the world and his wife wants the naval blockade of Gaza lifted, the BBC gushes that "The blockade on the Gaza Strip "must be broken", the head of the Arab League Amr Moussa has said." Odd then how they are less than effusive about sharing the news that Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas has told Obama that the naval blockade must be retained, lest it bolster Hamas. I guess not all news is equal...

17 comments:

TrueToo 11:36 AM, June 13, 2010  

Abbas has to do a delicate juggling act, pretending to be concerned about Hamas and co. since they are fellow Palestinians while also trying to hold onto his shaky leadership of the PA. If that were not enough, he has to subdue his natural impulse to proudly celebrate the "martyrs" who slaughter Israeli children and keep the celebrations low key in case they might be picked up by the Western left who might then gain a dim idea of who Abbas is and what his aims are, but not that low key that the Arab street will accuse him of totally selling out to the US and Israel.

Poor guy, I almost feel sorry for him.

The BBC has never honestly disussed these dilemmas, and never will.

What is the reprehensible Franks still doing "reporting" on the conflict. I suppose he's working in a notice period, so he'll be inflicting his "journalism" on us for a while still.

Cassandra King 3:04 PM, June 13, 2010  

The BBC narrative is that Palestinian brotherly solidarity should be pimped at every opportunity, they simply do not want Joe Public to know the actual truth of a bitter fued and venomous mutual loathing not only between hamas and fatah but between the various tribes and gangs.
Only a race hate campaign against the hated Jews brings a veneer of comradeship as thin as a sheet of tissue paper so the BBC pimps this solidarity to the public lest they realise that all that aid swallowed by the tens of billions has simply been wasted on a infighting bunch of rats in a sack. All the vast aid does apart from enriching the gangsters is prolong the hatred in the region and perhaps that is the plan.

sue 9:25 PM, June 13, 2010  

William Hague and Nick Clegg are pushing for unfettered access to and from Gaza. William Hague must have changed his mind since saying, immediately after the flotilla drama,  that lifting the blockade at this time would look like a victory for Hamas.
If that’s what Mahmoud Abbas thinks too, I take it that this doesn’t bother the government; or the BBC. Not to mention what it would mean for Israel.

deegee 9:29 PM, June 13, 2010  

Abbas is completely scared that in the event of achieving a two state solution the Islamists will do to him what they did in Gaza and Israel will do nothing to stop it. He just can't openly say it.

hippiepooter 10:38 PM, June 13, 2010  

The only person to shed tears over the Gazza strip was Paul Gascoigne.

David Preiser (USA) 11:18 PM, June 13, 2010  

I'm tired of hearing this nonsense about how the blockade - or anything else Israel does - somehow strengthens Hamas' position in Gaza.  Who the hell else is waiting in the wings to take over?  It's total BS.

There's no other faction waiting to fill the vaccuum left behind if Hamas magically loses popularity or whatever.  Who does the BBC or Hague or any lurking defenders of the indefensible think is capable of challenging Hamas in Gaza these days?  It's ridiculous.  Hamas had control before the blockade went up, and if concrete and building materials and all the other stuff coming through the tunnels was let in legally, Hamas would be even stronger.

This idea that Hamas somehow has a stronger grip on Gaza because of the blockade is an absolute joke.

John Horne Tooke 12:14 AM, June 14, 2010  

Indeed David - the people of Gaza love Hamas and the Isrealis are to blame for strengthening their support.

It could have nothing to do with the people of Gaza being terrified of Hamas could it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I1M4eH9Kk7I&feature=related

Biodegradable 12:29 AM, June 14, 2010  

Talk about selective, and balance!

Check out the related links on this page:

Israel sets up inquiry into deadly Gaza flotilla raid

Related internet links Israeli governmentWitnessGAZA flotilla updatesFree Gaza movement

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
The BBC <span>is</span> responsible for deciding to post one link to the Israeli government and TWO links to the terror enablers!

No room for this one?
http://www.flotillafacts.com/

John Horne Tooke 12:31 AM, June 14, 2010  

Here is the second part

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zpFaa80FpIQ

Biodegradable 12:31 AM, June 14, 2010  

<span>Talk about selective, and balance!  
 
Check out the related links on this page:  
 
Israel sets up inquiry into deadly Gaza flotilla raid  
 
Related internet links </span>
<span>Israeli government</span>
<span>WitnessGAZA flotilla updates</span>
<span>Free Gaza movement  
 
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites  </span>
<span>
The BBC <span>is</span> responsible for deciding to post one link to the Israeli government and TWO links to the terror enablers!  
 
No room for this one?  
http://www.flotillafacts.com/</span>

Cassandra King 6:27 AM, June 14, 2010  

There are two reasons why hamas is gaining power:

1) unlimited no strings free aid and money to pay off its gangster leaders.
2) Useful idiot collaborators forcing the above policy of no strings unlimited aid so hamas can continue the racist jihad without worring about actually caring for its own population.

The aid is the problem, the UNRWA is the problem, the refugee camps are the problem, stop the flow of terrorist support and you cripple hamas for good and peace can reign but not before the aid is used to make it happen.

Guest Who 7:15 AM, June 14, 2010  

'<span>Talk about selective, and balance!'</span>

Just watched on Breakfast News the 'report' on the enquiry to be set up.
What was left in (footage used); what was left out, and the tone used all point to every selective and editorial technique that is and will be deployed to make sure this narrative is enhanced to suit.

DP111 12:53 PM, June 14, 2010  

I dont think Egypt is too keen on Hamas either.

deegee 9:17 PM, June 14, 2010  

Hamas declares itself to be a part of the Muslim Brotherhood. The Brotherhood is banned in Egypt, and members have been arrested for their participation in it. The connection to violence is disputed but the Egyptian government clearly believes it and over the years has done much, including torture to limit the group's activities.<span></span>

Grant 9:38 AM, June 15, 2010  

Cassie,
The same applies to the "Arab World" in general.  Arab solidarity, don't make me laugh !

Grant 9:43 AM, June 15, 2010  

The BBC is strangely quiet about Egypt generally. How dare Egypt not follow the BBC's narrative.

David Preiser (USA) 4:36 PM, June 15, 2010  

It wasn't until a few months ago that the BBC even mentioned Egypt's involvement at all, or the fact that they had a border with Gaza.  Until recently, it was always the "Israeli blockade", full stop, with no mention of Egypt's border at all, except for that one time when the Palestinians stormed it and broke through.  I complained about it here for years until they changed it.

I have no idea what forced this change in editorial policy, but I'm glad they did it.  It's still not enough, especially considering the tunnels come from the Egyptian side, but it's better than it used to be.  It would be interesting to know what caused the BBC to be more honest about it, though.

Antony Jay

"But we were not just anti-Macmillan; we were anti-industry, anti-capitalism, anti-advertising, anti-selling, anti-profit, anti-patriotism, anti-monarchy, anti-Empire, anti-police, anti-armed forces, anti-bomb, anti-authority. Almost anything that made the world a freer, safer and more prosperous place, you name it, we were anti it."
Antony Jay, Telegraph, July 2007

Andrew Marr

"..the final answer, frankly, is the vigorous use of state power to coerce and repress. It may be my Presbyterian background, but I firmly believe that repression can be a great, civilising instrument for good. Stamp hard on certain 'natural' beliefs for long enough and you can almost kill them off."
Andrew Marr, The Guardian Feb. 1999

Jeremy Paxman

"But the bigger question is whether the BBC itself has a future. Working for it has always been a bit like living in Stalin’s Russia, with one five-year-plan, one resoundingly empty slogan after another. One BBC, Making it Happen, Creative Futures, they all blur into one great vacuous blur. I can’t even recall what the current one is. Rather like Stalin’s Russia, they express a belief that the system will go on forever."
Jeremy Paxman, The James McTaggart Memorial, 24th August 2007

Back to TOP